According to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, alligator mothers lay an average of thirty-eight eggs in a clutch. Thanks to predation, they won’t all hatch. Of the twenty-five or so that do, ten will make it to their first birthday and only five will reach adulthood.
That’s a survival rate of 13%, which doesn’t sound so bad for reptiles. But if that’s the survival rate of our creative projects, we might not be so thrilled. I’m here to assert that it’s not only okay to have such a low batting average, but in some ways it’s actually good for us.
The simple reason for this is that it’s an opportunity to develop our discernment, which derives from the Latin discernere (set apart or separate). This word has dropped out of fashion recently because it implies exclusivity and judgment. We expect discerning people to be exacting, difficult to please, and snobby in their pursuit of perfection. The word conjures up thoughts of judgy editors and critics who look for ways to reject our work without really reading it (you know the kind).
But that species of discernment lives on the outside of the creative process, so as writers we don’t need to worry about it. We can only control how we relate to our material and how we shape it on the page. The discernment I want to focus on is internal and an integral part of the creative process, and it’s important to separate it mentally from the external kind.
We invoke our internal discernment on a sentence or line level when we ask ourselves whether a word or phrase is our best choice in the moment. But we also use it in a more global sense as we look at the pipeline of works in progress that we could choose to pursue. Which ones are we going to nurture past the early drafts and into the adulthood of completion, when we feel comfortable publishing them?
The alligator eggs metaphor is admittedly imperfect because environmental and biological factors determine whether baby gators live or die, while human choice is almost always the determining factor for literary projects. Nothing but our own level of interest and commitment determines if we finish pieces or abandon them, whether after several unsatisfying drafts or even just a few notes. At whichever stage we abandon projects, it can be hard to accept that we are actively choosing to discontinue them. We tend to think we’re letting them die some inevitable, natural death instead of actively terminating them because it sounds cruel and violent—like “Kill your darlings” taken to its literal extreme.
But that’s exactly what we do when we starve a project of our effort and attention. We take one of our alligator eggs out of the nest and declare that this one won’t grow up. If we decide not to sugarcoat that decision but instead articulate why we made it, then we put ourselves on the road to becoming better writers by practicing a particular type of internal discernment: distinguishing our best work from all the rest, and the work we must do from the work we might do.
This is an underrated skill. Imagine that every project idea we’ve ever had deserves our full attention until it reaches adulthood. I’m not talking about the ones we actually start, but also the ones we’ve envisioned. If all projects are created equal, we’ll be working 24/7 and have zero friends. Distinguishing between must projects and might projects is essential to managing our creativity, and it’s a natural defense mechanism against wasting our time and diluting the overall quality of our work. So why not look at it as a skill we can develop?
To flesh this idea out, I’d like to switch my metaphor from the reptilian to the botanical. When pruning trees, arborists make conscious decisions about how energy flows within them. Narrowing the tree’s width helps energy rise up from the roots toward the apex, while removing lower branches from the trunk helps others grow outward and provide shade. Our powers of discernment are our pruning tools, and the more skillfully we’re able to wield them, the better we’ll manage the energy system of our own creative output.
Unfortunately, the pruning experience in creative work rarely works as smoothly and efficiently as an arborist’s saw. In my own practice, it’s messy and overemotional every single time. Among my students over the years, it has even induced tremendous self-doubt—especially when they equate killing off a project with killing off their writing aspirations. This confusion can easily happen when we put too much pressure on our projects, hunting for “the one” that will somehow springboard our careers and become the first piece we publish, the first book we sell, the first prizewinner we write.
These are worthy breakthroughs, certainly. But they all involve factors beyond our control, and it’s risky to externalize discernment in this way. Once we start assessing our own projects based on how we think they’ll be perceived by others, there’s almost no escape from the habit. And it’s too easy to give discernment the face of an exacting, hard-to-please, and snobby perfectionist who’s more than ready to reject our work—in other words, our own personal censor.
The antidote to this situation, and the key to teaching ourselves a more useful kind of discernment, are to (a) keep it internal, and (b) keep it conscious. Most of the projects we conceive will only be seen by us, so subjecting them to an imaginary public scrutiny makes zero sense. If our discernment is internal, and we make our primary question whether we love a project enough to continue revising it over the long haul, then we’re better able to make clear decisions. Hand in hand with that clarity also comes articulateness about why we’re making those decisions, which is crucial to the development of our own personal aesthetic. Saying “I’m abandoning this project because now I think it sucks” teaches us little about our own process. But saying “I’m abandoning it because my protagonist seem incapable of change” tells us a whole lot about not only our aesthetic, but also the kinds of things we need in our projects.
The solution, as is usually true with any writing problem, is an honest conversation with oneself. I like to set up this conversation by periodically batch reviewing my project ideas, some of which have been sitting in my nest like alligator eggs for decades. I set aside time to look at a bunch of them at once so I can put on my “discernment hat” and assess them in relation to each other. This process usually clicks in when I feel a new idea coming on that will make my nest of eggs too crowded, at which point I need to reshuffle them and take a few out. I’ll dig out my IDEAS file folders—I usually have several at any given time, with slightly different names like POSSIBILITIES and VARIOUS PROJECTS—and lay them all out on the floor.
Then I read through what I have and assess each one, which is easier to do in a batch because I’m asking the same question of many different projects rather than getting too deep into any one. A story I cooked up a year ago but never fleshed out because it felt too derivative will get the heave-ho—the equivalent of letting a raccoon steal an unhatched alligator egg. A poem cycle I started drafting six months ago but abandoned will get the axe because its language is too stilted and self-conscious for me to stick with. (I guess that’s the equivalent of feeding a hatchling to the hawks.) Yet a set of notes from thirty years ago might make the cut one more time because I simply love the characters too much to say goodbye, and because I dream of a self who’s calm enough to take on the project.
When I’ve gone through as much of my pile of ideas as I can handle (and I rarely get through it all) I add some paper to my recycling pile and step out of discernment mode, ready to shift gears. Is it time to start something new or refine something old? The answer varies, and my next step might not be to work on one of the alligator eggs in the nest at all. But my engagement with what’s in the nest does me good on whatever project I bounce to next. Because by getting into conversations with myself about what I want from my projects and why some survive while others die, I’ve become more aware of my own process. I’ve learned something about myself as a writer that I can carry in any direction I step.